Teachers’ Beliefs about Biliteracy Instruction:
Commonalties, Divergence & Dilemma

Presented at the
National Association for Bilingual Education Conference
Denver, Colorado
January 29, 1999

Jill Kerper Mora
San Diego State University
 

2/19/99

Click here to start

Table of Contents

Teachers’ Beliefs about Biliteracy Instruction: Commonalties, Divergence & Dilemma 

Research Question 1

Research Question 2

Design of the Study

The TORP classifies teachers according to three orientations:

Approaches to Bilingual & Second-Language Reading (BIA) 

Factors in Teachers’ Selection of Reading Approaches for LM Students 

Calexico Staff Development Activities 1992-1996

B/CLAD Credentials Calexico School District 

Bilingual/ELD Program

Teachers' Language Preferences for Reading

Teachers' Literacy History

TORP Approach Preferences Distribution

Biliteracy Instructional Approaches Subscales Patterns of Beliefs

Findings of the BIA Study

Differences in Teachers’ Beliefs about Biliteracy Instruction

ANOVA BIA Subscales & Teacher Characteristics

ANOVA BIA Subscales & Teacher Characteristics

ANOVA BIA Subscales & Teacher Characteristics

Conclusions

Author: Jill Kerper Mora
Copyright 1999

E-mail Dr. Mora 
with your comments



Return to Dr. Mora's Home Page



To MoraModules Menu
 

Click here to read more about the debate over approaches to reading instruction

Click here for an analysis of California's SAT 9 reading scores for ELLs 1998-99

Click here to read Dr. Mora's review of national testing policies for language minority students.

Click here for an instructional module on second-language reading.

Click here for a newspaper article about Calexico Unified School District's bilingual education program

The Calexico Success Story

According to a recent study conducted by professors from San Diego State University (Mora, Jones & Palacio, 1999) the Calexico Unified School District tells a remarkable success story. Although according to the demographic characteristics of its school population, there would be a predicted drop-out rate of 31%, Calexico’s rate for students not completing high school is only 14% annually. Twenty percent of Calexico High School graduates go on to four year universities, while another 58% continue their education at a community college. Of students statewide who are admitted to the University of California system, Hispanics include 3.8%. Among Hispanic students from Calexico, the admissions rate to the UC system is almost double the predicted rate, at seven percent of graduates.

University researchers and school officials attribute Calexico’s success in producing high achievement for Hispanic students to several factors. First, the outstanding leadership of administrators is credited for the soundness of the educational plan and the coherence of the overall program. Second, intensive and long-term inservice training of teachers has been provided to ensure effective implementation of the program. The innovative programs for addressing the linguistic and cultural needs of the students are thoroughly understood and supported by Calexico's teachers. This level of "buy-in" to the program by educators is reflected in a high level of involvement and support from parents and the local community.

The Calexico Unified School District (CUSD), which serves a student population that is 79 percent limited English proficient, has been nationally recognized by the National Association for Bilingual Education for its enriched bilingual education program that stresses academic excellence for all students. Among the reasons cited for the award was the school district’s success in achieving low drop-out rates and a high percentages of continuation of students in higher education (Scheibe, 1994). According to a survey conducted in 1994 in the preliminary phase of this study, the school drop-out rate in Calexico is eleven to fifteen percent, half of the California average for Latino students. Among graduates of Calexico High School, seven percent qualify for the highly competitive University of California system, as opposed to 3.8% for Latino students statewide. Seventy-eight percent of Calexico graduates went on to community college in 1994 while 13% enrolled in a four-year college or university.

This degree of success for a school district stands in sharp contrast to expectations based on district demographics (Moll & González, 1994). In addition to the NABE award, the Calexico District was recognized by the International Reading Association for the raises in achievement of at-risk students in kindergarten through third grade in reading through the Chapter I program. The district was commended for the implementation of the model of transitional reading from Spanish to English that resulted in increases in basic skills test scores for students in the district (Ward & Scheibe, 1993).

Another reason for the successes of the Calexico district is the high percentage of teachers in the district who hold a bilingual teaching Bilingual Cross-cultural Language and Academic Development (BCLAD) emphasis credential or its equivalent, the Bilingual Certificate of Competence (BCC). Between the holders of the BCLAD and BCC, seventy-seven percent of the Calexico elementary teachers hold credentials in bilingual education. Six percent are certified as Language Development Specialists, with specialized training in teaching LEP students.

 References

Moll, L.C., & González, N. (1994). Lessons from research with language-minority children. Journal of Reading Behavior 26 (4), 349-355.

Mora, J.K., Jones, E.B., & Palacio, E.J. (1999). The Calexico Success Story: Identifying variables in the literacy achievement of Hispanic students. National Association for Bilingual Education Conference, Denver, CO, January.

Scheibe, J. (1994, February 22). Bilingual award for Calexico. Imperial Valley Press, pp. A1, A8.

Ward, D. & Scheibe, J. (1993, April 12). School gets recognition. Imperial Valley Press, pp. A2, A6.

 For Additional Resources on Language and Literacy Instruction:

 

Return to 
Dr. Mora's Home Page

MoraModules Index

PLC 915 Syllabus

ED 516 Syllabus

TE 930 Reading/Language Arts 
Methods Syllabus
TE 639 Language & Literacy
Syllabus
Learn more about
L2 Reading
Learn more about Transition in 
Biliteracy Instruction
Learn more about
Spanish Reading
Heuristic Analysis of L2 Reading Performance
Biliteracy and L2 Reading Bibliography Effective Schooling Practices for 
Language Minority Students
To Prepare for the RICA Exam SAT-9 Reading Scores in
the Post-227 Era
A Roadmap to Effective 
ELD Instruction
A Biliteracy Curriculum Framework

 

This page was last updated on 07/26/02