This printer friendly version
collects all
the ICARE segments for this module on one page.
Clicking links may lead to confusion.
Module 2
Education and Training in Context
Introduction
and a little history
adapted from the SCANS report and the writings of
Thomas G. Sticht
The
last two decades have seen major changes in thinking about training and
education. In spite of political differences about educational goals,
a broad social consensus has emerged that schooling needs to prepare people
better for life and help students to apply their knowledge and skills in
realistic contexts.
In this module, we'll examine policies and principles for
developing "contextualized" training and education and the research that
supports the policies and principles, focusing specifically on Functional
Context Education (FCE). Then we'll invite you to work with fellow
students to apply your understanding to several instructional design case
studies.
By the end of this module, you should be able to:
Describe the origins, purpose, and advantages of
Functional Context Education.
Describe some fundamental features, limitations, and
capabilities of human cognition as they relate to the design of technical
training.
Articulate FCE-based design principles and strategies and
describe ways they might be applied to instructional design opportunities
and problems.
Functional Context Education
The work of Thomas G. Sticht and his
associates. They painstakingly uncovered important evidence about what
works in technical education and training by analyzing successful job and
literacy training programs. Although originally focused on the needs of
marginally literate youth and adults, many FCE design principles are broadly
applicable for a wide variety of educational needs.
What is Functional Context Education?
Functional Context Education is an approach to education that is based
upon a cognitive science theory of cognitive development, learning, and
instruction. The theoretical framework and the principles for applying this
framework to the task of instructional development are discussed in this
notebook.
Literacy is given special attention in FCE because of its importance to
all schooling and instruction in our information age. A general thesis is
that the idea that literacy is something one must "get" in one program,
which is then "applied" in another is misleading. Rather, it is argued that
literacy is developed while it is being applied. This means that for the
large numbers of youth and adults who read between the fifth and ninth grade
levels, literacy and content skills education can be integrated. Therefore,
there is no need for special "remedial" literacy programs to get students to
"prerequisite" levels of literacy before they are permitted to study the
"real thing."
In overview, education based on functional context theory includes the
following conceptual framework:
Society and culture
provide the most
important resources for human cognitive development. These resources
include symbols and symbol systems, such as the natural language and
conceptual (in contrast to perceptual) knowledge, which constitute the
primary means for the transmission of cognitive abilities.
The learner possesses a "human cognitive system"
with an
internal knowledge base "inside the head" and access to an external
knowledge base in the world "outside the head." The learner has a working,
or short term memory in which processing skills such as language are used
to move information in and out of both the internal and external knowledge
bases.
Learning is information processing
whereby the learner
actively seeks out information used in constructing a meaningful
interpretation of the world and a knowledge base comprised of these
interpretations.
A developmental perspective of literacy
emphasizing the
development of oral language from earlier prelinguistic knowledge and
literacy as the amalgam of prelinguistic, linguistic and graphic symbolic
knowledge.
The importance of context
in learning new information
and in transferring information already learned to new and different
problems and situations.
The application of this theoretical framework to the instructional
development process suggests creating courses that facilitate learning on
entry into the course, learning throughout the course, and transfer into the
contexts for which the learning is meant to apply. To accomplish these
objectives, courses should be developed that:
Explain what the students are to learn and why in such a way
that they can always understand both the immediate and long term
usefulness of the course content (facilitates entry into the course;
motivates learning).
Consider the old knowledge that students bring with them to the
course, and build new knowledge on the basis of this old knowledge
(facilitates entry learning).
Sequence each new lesson so that it builds on prior knowledge
gained in the previous lessons (facilitates in-course learning).
Integrate instruction in reading, writing, arithmetic, and
problem solving into academic or technical training programs, as the
content of the course poses requirements for information processing using
these skills that many potential students may not possess; avoid decontextualized basic skills "remedial" programs (facilitates in-course
learning; motivates basic skills learning; reduces instruction time;
develops "learning to learn" ability ).
Derive objectives from careful analysis of the explicit and
tacit knowledge and skill needed in the home, community, academic,
technical training, or employment context for which the learner is
preparing (facilitates transfer).
Use, to the extent possible, reading contexts, tasks,
materials, and procedures taken from the future situation in which the
learner will be functioning (facilitates transfer).
Why is FCE Important for
Youth and Adult Education?
Unlike children, who tend to do things to please their parents or
teachers, youth and adults will usually want to understand the functional
utility of investing time and mental energy in learning something. With
respect to out-of-school youth and adults then, FCE focuses on Improving:
(1) Participation in adult education programs by making explicit
the relationship between what students want to learn, what is being taught,
and its application in the contexts that the person will be functioning in
after the educational program. This promotes increased motivation.
(2) Achievement in learning and transfer by ensuring that
instruction relates to the learner's prior knowledge in such a way that the
learner can function within the learning situation and improving transfer by
deriving instructional contents as much as possible from the future contexts
in which the person will apply the reading.
(3) Prevention of learning problems in future generations by
designing youth and adult programs that maximize the intergenerational
transfer of the adults' new skills and attitudes about education to their
children.
Use the I-CARE menu on the left
to advance to Connect.
Module 2
Education and Training in Context
Connect
Abridged and re-organized from
Functional Context
Education: Making Learning Relevant
by Thomas G. Sticht
This portion of the
module provides an overview of issues and methods involving functional
context education principles.
Cognitive Science Foundations
Required reading; read in depth--approximately 45 pages broken
into three chapters, all in this Connect section.
For your convenience, you can simply print out this
page to have a hard copy of this important content.
These three chapters provide a summary of contemporary cognitive
science as it relates to functional context education. They show how the
concepts of functional context education relate to other advances in
educational research in recent decades. Concepts such as the social basis
of cognition and literacy, constructivism, situated cognition, situated
practice, contextual learning, anchored instruction, problem-based
learning, cooperative learning, multiliteracies, and multiple modes of
representation are among the many ideas that are discussed in relation to
functional context education in these chapters.
Case Studies in Functional Context Education
Includes Chapters 7,8,9, and 10. These chapters, which will be
presented in the Reflect section of this module, provide four case
studies of programs that illustrate how the principles of functional
context education can be applied to curriculum development and assessment.
We will use these chapters for a group discussion. You will be
assigned one chapter to read for this discussion. More on this in
the Reflect section.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Apply segment.
Module 2
Education and Training in Context
Apply
This section examines case studies
that describe successful applications of FCE policies and principles and the
SITE Model to typical instructional problems. Rather than requiring
you to read all the case studies, we'll ask that you read one case
study, use an online form to post an analysis, and prepare a 5-minute
presentation to a group about that case study.
DE
Students: We will ask for volunteer to deliver their
presentations orally through Breeze
Which chapter to read and prepare?
(these
chapters are not included in the printer-friendly page)
If your last name begins with...read
and prepare...
Before completing this Applysection, you'll need to review your EDTEC 540 notes on writing
objectives and review Robert Mager's Goal Analysis and
Preparing Instructional Objectives.
Then you'll use your understanding of
FCE, The Site Model, and how to write goals and objectives to complete the
following analysis of the chapter. Be prepared to walk a small
discussion group through your analysis in a concise 5-minute presentation.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Reflect segment.
Module 2
Education and Training in Context
Reflect
Instructional designers sometimes call the
approach we're using to discuss the FCE case studies a jigsaw strategy
because each participant in the discussion group will have read something
different. But nobody will have "all the answers" because each person
has done different research. In some respects, this approach
simulates a work team where different specialists or people with different
points of view come together to analyze or solve a problem.
You will work in groups to discuss
one of the following questions (draw straw) and then share your thoughts
with the class. Please take good notes of your discussion.
Analysis of Proposed QED
Projects. How would you apply FCE and the SITE Model to the
analysis of learners and subcontexts for your proposed QED project?
Ask one person to be the group's "guinea pig" and help that person to
work through the analysis of their project's proposed learners using the
SITE model. Help the person to describe the sociocultural context,
informational context, and technical context associated with prospective
learners.
Automaticity. How do
automated cognitive "skills" reduce demands on working memory and how
does insufficient automaticity of basic skills interfere with
development of "higher order" abilities such as critical thinking and
metacognition?
Build your explanation around an example from your own experience as an
educational technology student.
What about decontextualization?
What does it mean to say that education or instruction is
decontextualized? What are the drawbacks of decontextualized instruction
and education? Are there any benefits of learning decontextualized
subject matter, and if so, what are these benefits? Briefly describe a
past (formal) learning experience where you were taught abstractions
(e.g., theory) first and then taught to apply the abstractions to
concrete circumstances. Then outline how you would apply FCE methods to
rework the structure of this learning experience so that it would
proceed from concrete to abstract.
Use the I-CARE menu on the
left to
advance to the Extend segment.
Module 2
Education and Training in Context
Extend
Optional Resources
Extend
your understanding about learning in context with these links and follow up
activities.
Optional: Read more about the power of adult literacy
Primarily of interest to adult educators. Includes
3 Chapters (not
included in printer-friendly page).